Abstract Abiotic hydrogen (H2) generation from water‐rock interactions is traditionally attributed to iron‐mediated redox chemistry; which fails to explain H2 release from low‐iron minerals like pure forsterite. Using density functional theory and molecular dynamics simulations of olivine surfaces, we identify an alternative, defect‐mediated mechanism. We demonstrate that undercoordinated silicate sites on magnesium‐rich olivine act as effective catalytic centers, driving spontaneous water dissociation via surface‐induced Lewis acid–base interactions independent of iron redox activity. Bader charge analysis confirms that local charge redistribution controls reactivity. Conversely, the stable fayalite surface possesses a high charge density that suppresses water dissociation. Simulations reveal that rapid proton hopping across silicate networks links initial water dissociation to surface transport, providing the necessary spatial prerequisite for eventual H2 recombination. These findings decouple H2 production from iron availability, implying that widespread forsterite‐bearing silicate rocks may be previously unrecognized sources of abiotic H2 in shallow crustal and sub‐seafloor settings.