Abstract Secondary ice production (SIP) remains a major uncertainty in understanding deep convection because its rates and controlling conditions are poorly constrained. Using the Tracking Aerosol Convection Interactions Experiment (TRACER) C‐band and operational S‐band radar observations, Houston Lightning Mapping Array (HLMA) lightning data, and large‐eddy simulations (LESs), this study investigates negative KDP ${K}{text{DP} }$ observed above the melting layer as a potential signature of SIP and storm electrification. Among 413 observed deep convective cells, 238 cases (∼57.6%) exhibit negative KDP ${K}{text{DP} }$ above the melting layer, and 49 of 123 lightning‐active cases (∼39.8%) show negative KDP ${K}{text{DP} }$ near HLMA sources. These observations suggest that negative KDP ${K}{text{DP} }$ is associated with small, vertically oriented, electrically aligned ice particles. LESs with spectral bin microphysics reproduce negative KDP ${K}_{text{DP} }$ with high likelihood only when SIP is included, especially fragmentation of freezing drops, which increases ice water path, decreases liquid water path, and reduces accumulated precipitation by ∼11.2% in the examined case.