Abstract Recent observations indicate two distinct drivers of interrupted winter convection in the Labrador Sea: anomalous atmospheric forcing and the advection of freshwater anomalies. Here we test whether these mechanisms arise spontaneously under stationary pre‐industrial climate conditions using six medium to high‐resolution CMIP6 control simulations. We identify recurrent shutdowns of Subpolar Gyre deep convection driven primarily by persistent negative NAO phases, which suppress winter surface heat loss and inhibit convective preconditioning. In addition, rare but more persistent shutdowns occur when freshwater anomalies of Arctic origin reach the Labrador Sea, enhancing stratification and sea‐ice formation. Our results demonstrate that both observed drivers of Labrador Sea convection interruption are intrinsic features of internal variability of state‐of‐the‐art climate models, providing a baseline for assessing how these drivers respond to anthropogenic warming.