With just three official days of talks left, the catch-all initial draft of the cover decision – which the Arab Group and Russia say they reject – has yet to be slimmed down. To speed things up, the COP31 presidency has asked governments to send their top people to a meeting at 5pm local time dubbed a ‘Divan’, a word derived from an Ottoman council. There, they are being encouraged to respond to the question: ‘How can COP31 send signals and capture a clear plan of action which meets the moment, while respecting national circumstances and priorities?’ Participants are encouraged to speak directly to each other rather than just reading out statements to the chair, who – despite Australia’s role as President of Negotiations – will be COP31 President Murat Kurum. The aim is to ‘explain where their delegations see room for common ground and what they would need to reach agreement’ on a text that is intended to be the cherry on the cake of ‘a balanced package’ including negotiated agenda items. A handful of observer groups will also be present in the room. It is unclear whether the next version of the text will come out before or after the ‘Divan’ meeting. The presidency has said only that it will be published as soon as possible. COP31 Bulletin Day 8: EU backs electrification goal, as more TAFF roadmaps promised Before then on Wednesday, we are expecting announcements from a group of countries aiming for net negative emissions and we will be hearing from the European Union again at a 2pm press conference. There will also be a ministerial event to launch the next Global Stocktake of national climate plans, which is due to conclude in 2028. One hot issue that has angered developing countries and campaigners alike this week is the reluctance of rich nations to put significant amounts of new finance on the table in Antalya, especially for adaptation, at a time when the impacts of global warming are hitting ever harder. A pledging session on Tuesday saw measly contributions of just $50 million for the Adaptation Fund against its annual target of $300 million. Panama minister: Consensus system dooms COPs to failure Panama’s environment minister Juan Carlos Navarro told a press conference on Wednesday morning that COPs ‘are doomed to failure’ because they rely on consensus. ‘For heaven’s sake, how can 192 countries agree by consensus on how to fix a crisis that they created and that most of the developed nations and the producers of fossil fuels are responsible for?’ he asked. ‘Our hearts are full of hope and goodwill, but we are crashing against a wall of perverse futility and the most blatant inflexibility from those who should lead the way,’ he said, before criticising COP delegates as ‘bureaucrats and moochers’ and people on ‘paid vacations’ who ‘fill the halls with AI-generated beautiful speeches’. ‘It’s about time the world grows up, and each nation accepts individual responsibility and stops hiding behind the smoke curtain of COPs and the miraculous way which they supposedly will fix, in this international fora by consensus, problems which we know will not be fixed with these exercises in hypocrisy,’ he blasted. Juan Carlos Navarro, Minister of Environment for Panama, pictured on October 30, 2024. (Photo by IISD/ENB Mike Muzurakis) Juan Carlos Navarro, Minister of Environment for Panama, pictured on October 30, 2024. (Photo by IISD/ENB Mike Muzurakis) The UNFCCC has responded to calls for reform of the UN climate process including COPs by consulting with a panel of experts. In Antalya, countries have also been airing their views on the topic in presidency-led consultations, which has angered some governments like Russia and the Arab nations. But abolishing the COP’s consensus-based system is unlikely because doing so would require consensus – which countries like Saudi Arabia have always fiercely opposed. The African Group is also against changing the rules – which have never been formally adopted – to a more nimble way of operating such as by majority voting. Its chair, Antwi-Boasiako Amoah of Ghana, defended veto power at the mid-year talks in June, telling journalists that ‘countries are sovereign, national interests are different, and you cannot sacrifice one party’s interest for another’s’. Some governments that want to move faster on thorny issues such as phasing out fossil fuels have formed so-called coalitions of the willing outside the UN climate talks, such as the Santa Marta process which brings together around 60 countries that want to plan their transition away from coal, gas and oil. The post COP31 Bulletin Day 9: Crunch ministerial talks planned for Wednesday evening appeared first on Climate Home News.

Read original article