With COP31 set to agree that governments should do more to protect the oceans, climate campaigners and diplomats have warned that this must not be interpreted as encouragement for ‘unproven’ marine-based geoengineering techniques. Oceans absorb about 30% of the world’s planet-warming carbon dioxide, reducing the impacts of climate change. Initial research suggests that they could absorb more if altered with through techniques like ocean alkalinity enhancement or ocean iron fertilisation, where iron is put in the ocean so that algae grows on it and sucks up carbon. The initial draft of the COP31 cover text contains a goal to increase carbon dioxide removal in general. Some ocean advocates said the link between this and oceans has not and should not be made. This language is contentious, with the EU opposed, and may not be in the final decision. A political call to action released yesterday by COP31 co-presidency Türkiye encourages countries to protect marine ecosystems like mangroves and seagrasses, recognising their carbon storage potential, but it avoids any mention of marine geoengineering techniques. At a COP31 press conference on Tuesday, Palau’s ambassador Ilana Seid said her Pacific country supported strong language on the protection of oceans but is concerned about marine carbon dioxide removal. ‘A lot of the science there is unproven and we are cautioning against that,’ she said. The main deal being negotiated in Antalya is the first one since the release of a major scientific report by the UN Environment Programme (UNEP) saying that overshooting the 1.5C temperature limit is now unavoidable and that, to bring temperatures back down, some technologies that remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere will be needed. Seid added that, while some CDR will be necessary, it should be ‘at the tail end of the equation’ and should not become a substitute for reducing emissions, an argument echoed by UNEP’s chief Inger Andersen at an event in Antalya. Nov 17, 2026 News Rich countries must step up to replenish Green Climate Fund, Duarte says GCF Executive Director Mafalda Duarte tells Climate Home News efforts to leverage the fund’s balance sheet more effectively and find new contributors do not mean letting wealthy donor nations off the hook Read more Nov 17, 2026 Comment Minerals for the planet or for war and AI? COP31 must make clear what we prioritise As demand for minerals soars, intensifying pressure for new mining, meeting demand for the energy transition must come first Read more Nov 16, 2026 News Countries take up industry push to loosen UN carbon market rules at COP31 A draft decision reflects demands from dozens of countries to reassess the UN carbon market’s integrity rules, a push campaigners blame on industry lobbying. Read more Uncertain impacts on nature Marine Lecerf, head of international policy at Ocean and Climate Platform, told reporters at COP31 on Tuesday that she is wary about marine carbon removal techniques, and that COP31’s strong push for ocean solutions should focus on more proven actions that cut carbon emissions. ‘There are many uncertainties surrounding [marine carbon dioxide removal’s] effectiveness, their scalability, their durability – but even more importantly, their potential adverse impact on nature,’ she said. A paper from earlier this year by the University of California and the US-based National Center for Atmospheric Research (NCAR) shows that, while ocean iron fertilisation’s impacts on nature ‘remain poorly understood’, disturbances may be stronger in some regions – like the equatorial Pacific – and lesser in others, like the Southern Ocean in Antarctica. Speaking next to Lecerf at a COP31 press briefing, former Canadian environment minister Steven Guilbeault said the focus should instead be on ocean solutions that have already been proven to work. ‘We can perhaps another day talk about those technologies if we’re going to need them,’ he said. Asked what solutions are available, young Samoan activist Brianna Fruean spoke of a project she saw at the pre-COP in Fiji last month where the villagers of Naidiri have stopped fishing in an area of their waters and are replanting coral that has been bleached. All the planters are volunteers though, she told Climate Home News, squeezing it in around their day jobs. With funding, they could be paid for their work – which began in 2009 – and restores the reef much faster, she added. Push for ocean roadmap that informs next global stocktake grows at COP31 More research needed? But some ocean advocates support research into these techniques. Kilaparti Ramakrishna, oceans and climate advisor at the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution – which helped organise the COP31 oceans pavilion – told Climate Home News in September that research should be conducted into these techniques. Ramakrishna said these techniques ‘have great potential in taking the carbon out of the atmosphere’ and that scientific studies show that ‘it works’ on a small scale. But, he said, the impacts on the environment if it is scaled up to draw a billion tonnes of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere are poorly understood. ‘So, we need to figure that out,’ he said. Woods Hole is conducting ocean iron fertilisation on a 10 square kilometre area and monitoring it for two years. ‘We’re already doing field studies’, said Ramakrishna, adding ‘those are the kinds of things that make the ocean a hero in terms of solving the climate problem. But we should always be mindful that in solving one problem we don’t create other problems’. Back in September, Ramakrishna defended Woods Hole’s work, saying it does not take corporate money for its marine geongineering studies but only philanthropic foundations or governmental grants. It seeks permits from governments which involves long conversations and consultations, he added. Pushing back against criticism, he said: ‘Some environmental groups say ‘oh my god, that is really messing with the environment. We are messing with the ocean environment today. You know, we should be mindful of that.’ The post Ocean advocates warn COP31 agreement should not be read as geoengineering boost appeared first on Climate Home News.