Abstract High Salinity Shelf Water (HSSW) in Terra Nova Bay, a key constituent of Antarctic Bottom Water (AABW), freshened from 1959 to 2014 before reversing in 2015. Variations in HSSW salinity influence AABW properties, global ocean heat and oxygen distribution. Yet, observations informing salinity trends are primarily collected during austral summer, months after HSSW is formed by wintertime brine rejection in Antarctic polynyas. We find that wintertime brine rejection only partly explains summertime HSSW salinity. Model simulations suggest that surface salinity in the preceding winter and HSSW residence time contribute to summertime salinity variability, while mooring and sea‐ice observations provide some evidence consistent with these mechanisms. This study highlights the importance of year‐round observations for improving our understanding of HSSW variability, temporal lags, and the future of AABW.