Abstract In multiwell saltwater disposal systems, induced earthquakes may reflect overlapping pressure changes, complicating assessment of individual wells’ contributions. Near Peace River, Alberta, multiple wells inject into the Leduc Formation, a fringing carbonate reef complex, including wells active for decades approximately 35km $35hspace{.5em}mathrm{k}mathrm{m}$ from the earthquake cluster center. Yet previous studies linked the 2022 sequence to a well about 5km $5hspace{.5em}mathrm{k}mathrm{m}$ away. We test whether its contribution to pressure averaged over a basement fault region exceeds that of all other wells combined. To address hydraulic uncertainty, we ran a diffusion ensemble using recorded injection histories from 15 wells and varying reservoir and fault permeabilities. Its contribution exceeded all others combined under some, but not all, sampled hydraulic conditions. Faster pressure transmission allowed decades of distant injection to prevent that well from dominating. Distant wells therefore warrant consideration as potential contributors to fault pressure loading when regional pressure transmission is poorly constrained.